Spectrum Occupancy Measurement of Cellular Spectrum and Smart Network Sharing in Pakistan

In wireless communication, the radio spectrum is a very rare and precious resource that has currently become a major problem to efficiently exploit the underutilized band of the static allocated licensed band. Recently, the cognitive radio (CR) has emerged as a promising technology to overcome the spectrum crisis, in which, the licensed band can be utilized by the unlicensed user until and unless it does not affect the transmission of the licensed band. In this paper, the spectrum occupancy of three bands i.e. GSM 900, 1800 and 2100 bands have been measured through spectrum analyzer in the indoor and outdoor environment. The measured results of all the three bands have been calculated through MATLAB against the power spectral density versus frequency plots. Results have shown that the majority of the licensed band is underutilized. Therefore, the CR can play a pivotal role to efficiently utilize the unused spectrum and to overcome the cellular wireless spectrum crisis in Pakistan. The second part of this paper deals with the emerging concept of network sharing among mobile operators and its impacts on cost. Network sharing become the standard among mobile operators worldwide and so in Pakistan. Capital (CAPEX) as well as operational (OPEX) expenditure and rapid advancement in technology encouraged all operators to go for sharing business models. In Pakistan, all four mobile operators Jazz, Telenor, Zong, and Ufone are actively adopting this model to maintain EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization). Mainly there are two types of network sharing, Passive infrastructure sharing, and active resource sharing. Passive network sharing is widely used in Pakistan among operators. Keywords—Cognitive radio; spectrum occupancy; cellular networks; spectrum analyzer; mobile network operators; sharing models; passive infrastructure sharing


I. INTRODUCTION
With the rapid evolution in wireless technological services, the demand to provide ubiquitous high data rates are increasing exponentially. This leads to utilizing the spectrum resource efficiently [1]- [2]. Thus, researchers have come up with an idea to utilize the unused spectrum through smart sensing of available spectrum through various technologies such as cognitive radio (CR). The CR can effectively deal with the spectrum scarcity problems also; it permits secondary users (SUs) to use the unoccupied spectrum without affecting the transmission of primary users (PUs) [3]- [4]. In the meantime, the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) investigated the spectrum occupancy and found that a major portion of the available spectrum is unused due to the static allocation technique [5][6] [7]. The CR technology is viewed as an efficient solution to mitigate the spectrum scarcity problem, which is expected to be used in 5G technologies. A CR is a smart communication system that senses the unused spectrum in its surrounding environment and adjusts its spectrum utilization according to its environment [8].
Dynamic Spectrum Access (DSA) is considered one of the predominant approaches to address the challenges of the unutilized spectrum. In DSA, the spectrum sensing is the first step to utilize the spectrum [9]. The primary user is preferred to use the band or channel over a secondary user whereby, a secondary user utilizes the available band in the absence of a primary user [10]. Different frequency bands have been considered in order to be utilized with a DSA. Out of which Very High Frequency (VHF) and Ultra High Frequency (UHF) bands are the most favorable ones. These bands are traditionally used for different applications such as for TV broadcasting, as an outcome, empty channels or frequency in these traditional bands are often called TV White Spaces (TVWSs) [11]. Several international regulatory bodies have proposed solutions to utilize spectral opportunities in TVWSs. One of the most important IEEE standards is IEEE 802.22 which was approved by IEEE in 2011 [12].
The number of subscribers of cellular networks worldwide is increasing at a very fast pace; with almost 164 million subscribers in Pakistan alone. There is an incessant requirement to build Cellular Network infrastructure to meet the demands of the ever-increasing number of mobile users and provide better services, mainly consists of a voice call, short message services (SMS) and data services. The main infrastructure is the Global System of Mobile Telecommunications (GSM) Base station that consists of the Base Transceiver System (BTS). In order to enhance footprint across the country at a rapid pace became challenging for every operator due to high Capital expenditure (CAPEX), increasing operational expenses (OPEX), government regulatory bodies' approvals, taxations, security issues, and infrastructure expenses, etc. To mitigate these challenges, the concept of network sharing emerged and opened new doors of opportunities for Mobile network operators [13]. Currently, there are four mobile operators Jazz, Telenor, Zong, and Ufone; serving the Pakistan Telecom industry and facing the same challenges [14]. This paper provides different scenarios of Network sharing among Mobile operators in Pakistan and the impact of Infrastructure sharing.
In the same context, whenever any operator intends for rollout, it involves huge investment and the necessity to recover it by imposing big charges on subscribers. This leads to less affordability and eventually discourages mobile service (IJACSA) International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications, Vol. 11, No. 3, 2020 233 | P a g e www.ijacsa.thesai.org providers to shift towards the next generations in this competitive market [15]. More or less, this problem is addressed with the help of network sharing business model in Pakistan. There are several pros of cellular sharing, increased revenue generation, growth in the number of subscribers and market penetration, fast network roll-out, avoids environmental hazardous, maintained control over mobility and above all the significant reduction in cost [16]. However, there are a few cons also, operators may lose independence over network strategy, the hidden cost may affect the revenue of a particular cluster and it is impossible to foresee everything that has to be the part of this agreement. Apparently, the advantages overweigh the disadvantages and it appeals to every mobile operator in the country to adopt the sharing business models for their future strategy.
In this paper, the spectrum occupancy measurement of all the GSM cellular operators of Pakistan in measured through spectrum analyzer in three different bands i.e. 900, 1800 and 2100 bands. The measurements are calculated at different locations of Pakistan including the Telecommunication Department of Mehran University of Engineering & Technology, Jamshoro on several days during university lab hours. The results are carried out in the form of power spectral density (PSD) for different bands of cellular operators working in Pakistan and its bandwidth utilization percentage. The measured results are very helpful for regulatory authorities such as Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) to revise spectrum occupancy policies and to promote strong competition among cellular operators and cheap rates because every operator intends to have less CAPEX & OPEX.
The formation of this paper is as follows. Section I contains the introduction. The measurement setup and occupancy measurement method are explained in Section II. The measured results are described in Section III. Section IV contains the concluding remarks and future work.

A. Measurement Setup
The spectrum occupancy measurements have been carried out at various locations of the Sindh region such as Nooriabad, Hyderabad, Autobahn Road, Qasimabad, Site Area and TD of MUET Jamshoro using Rohde & Schwarz FSH6 handheld spectrum analyzer (SA). The SA can operate in the range of 100 KHz to 6 GHz. The spectrum occupancy measurement setup has been demonstrated in Fig. 1, which shows that the GSM 900 antenna is attached to SA via optical fiber cable and the SA is connected to a laptop via optical USB cable. Moreover, the antenna configuration is shown in Table I. The measurements have been carried out for a month at different places of Sindh Region, Pakistan and each measurement has been carried out for about 30 minutes. The Rhode & Schwarz FSH view and MATLAB have been utilized to take records and plot them, respectively.

B. Cellular Operators of Pakistan
There are four GSM cellular mobile service providers working in Pakistan i.e. Telenor, Pakistan Mobile Communication Limited (PMCL/JAZZ), Ufone and Zong. These four cellular operators are using different techniques such as GSM, WCDMA, LTE and LTE-A services to provide its customers ubiquitous high-quality voice and data services [17]. The general methodology is illustrated in the flowchart given below in Fig. 2. The SA settings for GSM service providers and GSM 900, DCS 1800 and 2100 bands in Pakistan are illustrated in Table II.

III. OCCUPANCY RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The results of the SA measurement are represented in the average power spectral density (APSD) versus frequency plots in the MATLAB. The APSD is measured by averaging all the values gathered during a 30 days' measurement campaign for different bands i.e. GSM 900, 1800 and 2100 bands. The occupied spectrum calculation is done by setting a threshold level (a solid black line marked as a threshold level in all figures) as shown in Fig. 3 to Fig. 30. The half-power threshold is indicated by adding 3dBm in the minimum received power signal. If the measured APSD of a specific frequency is beyond the threshold level, then the certain frequency is called as occupied frequen, cy. The percentage of spectrum occupancy can be calculated as described in Eq. 1.
Where PT denotes the number of frequency measurements that exceed the selected threshold level and P is the total number of frequency measurement points in the specific spectrum band.

A. Mobilink
Mobilink started its cellular services as a pioneer operator in Pakistan in 1994 [18]. Recently, they have won the 10 MHz spectrum in the 1800 MHz band. Mobilink and Warid merged into a single company on November 26, 2015. Also, the recent merger of Jazz and Warid increased their subscribers of about 49 million around the country.
The results of indoor and outdoor GSM 900 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 3, 4, 5 and 6, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum www.ijacsa.thesai.org occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 61.794% and 61.4618%, respectively. These results conclude that a 5.82 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.2 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 58.1362% and 68.7708% respectively. These results conclude that a 5.47 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.2 MHz spectrum band.

B. UFONE
UFONE initiated its cellular services in Pakistan on January 29, 2001. Recently, it has launched its 4G services in major cities of Pakistan on February 9, 2019 [19].
The measured results of indoor and outdoor GSM 900 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are illustrated in Fig. 7, 8, 9 and 10, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 42.1927% and 91.0299% respectively. These results conclude that a 4.8 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.2 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 63.1229% and 86.711% respectively. These results conclude that a 3.8 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.2 MHz spectrum band.

C. Telenor
Telenor [17] is a multinational telecommunications company and it launched its GSM cellular services in the main cities of Pakistan on March 15, 2005. They have also won a 4G license spectrum of 10MHz block in 850 MHz in Pakistan.    The results of indoor and outdoor GSM 900 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 11, 12, 13 and 14, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 66.113% and 60.7973%, respectively. These results conclude that a 3.51 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 9.6 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 56.4784% and 66.7774% respectively. These results conclude that a 3.67 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 9.6 MHz spectrum band.

D. ZONG
Zong is the only cellular operator that is being owned by China and it launched its operation in Pakistan 1991 as Paktel by Cable & Wireless. Also, it is one of the first company which is allowed a free license to provide cellular phone services. Recently PTA has allotted a six months 5G trial license to check its coverage on non-commercial-basis [20].
The results of indoor and outdoor GSM 900 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 15, 16, 17 and 18, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 69.103% and 88.0399% respectively. These results conclude that the 3.34 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.2 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 62.4585% and 81.3953% respectively. These results conclude that the 4.26 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 15.6 MHz spectrum band.     238 | P a g e www.ijacsa.thesai.org

E. GSM 900
The results of indoor and outdoor GSM 900 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 19, 20, 21 and 22, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 57.1429% and 53.8206% respectively. These results conclude that 22.25 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 64.8 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 77.7409% and 56.8106% respectively. These results conclude that 16.35 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 64.8 MHz spectrum band.

F. DCS 1800
The measured results of indoor and outdoor GSM 1800 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 23, 24, 25 and 26 respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 43.12% and 62.13% respectively. These results conclude that 58.93 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 59.80% and 64.45% respectively. These results conclude that the 47.11 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 62.2 MHz spectrum band.

G. 2100 Band
The results of indoor and outdoor 2100 uplink and downlink spectrum occupancies are represented in Fig. 27, 28, 29 and 30, respectively. The measured results of indoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 43.52% and 77.07%, respectively. These results conclude that the 23.81 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 30 MHz spectrum band. Similarly, the measured results of outdoor spectrum occupancy for both uplink and downlink spectrum bands are 59.8% and 86.71% respectively. These results conclude that the 16.05 MHz spectrum band is unutilized out of the total 30 MHz spectrum band.
Spectrum occupancy and their related unused spectrum of all the GSM cellular operators and GSM 900, 1800 and 2100 bands are illustrated in Table III to Table IX. (IJACSA) International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications, Vol. 11, No. 3, 2020 240 | P a g e www.ijacsa.thesai.org

H. Smart Network Sharing
Undoubtedly, the prompt advancement in Telecommunication compels every Mobile operator in Pakistan to be more innovative for the growth of the business. Secondly, cellular customers in Pakistan are increasing at a very fast pace, especially data users. Incumbent operators, Jazz, Telenor, Zong, and Ufone are doing their best efforts to provide not only better services to existing customers but also in a bid to improve their coverage in every corner of the country. Nevertheless, all the mobile service providers are facing the difficult task of significantly increasing the capacity to meet projected demand while keeping CAPEX and OPEX down. In order to achieve the same, infrastructure sharing become a key consideration in operators' planning of the evolution of their networks in the current era. Fig. 31 is showing the number of mobile subscribers in Pakistan until the last quarter (November-2019).
Additionally, to further clarify this, the subscribers of every mobile operator are shown in Fig. 32. These pictures clearly depict the growth in subscribers with each year passing on.
A survey conducted in this project to find out the insights and status of network sharing in Pakistan among operators. Mostly, mobile operators are doing Passive infrastructure sharing due to government regulations. There are four models of Passive infrastructure sharing; model: 1) (Only site space and tower is shared), model: 2) (Site space, tower, and Commercial power is shared), model: 3) (Site Space, tower, Commercial power, and Genset backup is shared), model: 4) (Site Space, tower, commercial power, Genset backup, and DC power is shared). With respect to market share, Jazz is leading in the market and stands number one operator with 37%, while Telenor on second in a row with 28%, whereas Zong is on the third number with 19% and Ufone is on the fourth position with 15%. With these business opportunities and challenges, mobile operators are witnessing the hardest era in terms of cost. Therefore, to reduce these expenditures, network sharing proved to be the best solution for mobile operators in Pakistan. As per findings, the number of base transceiver stations (BTS) of four operators in Pakistan are shown in below Table X. www.ijacsa.thesai.org  Interestingly, Telenor is leading among all operators when it comes to network sharing in Pakistan with 37.52% of Telenor network is shared. While Ufone is on the second number in this competition with 27.69% of its shared network. Zong is on third with 25.78% of shared network and Jazz is the last one with 22.63% network sharing. This clearly shows the incline of all operators towards smart network sharing in the Pakistan Telecom industry as illustrated in Table X and Fig. 33.
As one of the biggest advantages of the network, sharing is cost-saving, therefore, the details of cost savings provided here. As per this research, operators bear the expenditure of base transceiver station in Pakistan consists of annual rental payment, electricity billing, security expenditure, operation, and maintenance expenditure.

IV. CONCLUSION
In this paper, we have carried out the spectrum occupancy measurements through SA and plot them in the MATLAB against frequency vs power spectral density. We have measured the spectrum occupancies of three bands i.e. 900, 1800 and 2100 bands for both indoor as well as outdoor spectrum bands and found out that the majority of the spectrum band is unutilized. The results of measured spectrum occupancies are illustrated in Table III to Table IX. In addition, it is noted that the overall bandwidth utilization ratio of all the cellular service providers is not 100%, which can be utilized with the help of CR. Thus, CR can be the optimal solution to improve the spectrum utilization ratio of all the three bands of uplink and downlink spectrum bands in Pakistan. Moreover, the Network sharing became the norm for Telecom industry to control cost and expenditure. terms of network sharing. Spectrum bands will become technological free/neutral as per the demand of this day and spectrum occupancy will play a vital role for it. Furthermore, it is likely that 3G infrastructure may vanish in future, as the 3G architecture entails extensive hardware replacing when shifting from 2G to 3G (expensive). 4G/LTE is an all IP network and do not need conventional hardware though it only requires switches and servers. It is therefore likely that a third party vendor/contractor may provide site allocation and infrastructure to cellular operators, reducing OPEX and CAPEX by the concept of smart network sharing.